Everton’s Quiet Probe: Celtic Receive Approach for Alistair Johnston — The Guru Weighs In

Everton have quietly contacted Celtic to check on the availability of right-back Alistair Johnston, Martin O’Neill confirmed, and the signal is clear: Toffees are hunting defensive reinforcements. This is not tabloid hyperbole; it is a measured enquiry from a club that believes Johnston could solve specific tactical problems on its right flank.

O’Neill’s public acknowledgement was careful — Celtic have had a phone call, but nothing progressed to an offer or negotiation yet. From Celtic’s perspective Johnston is an asset with recent international pedigree and they will extract value, either by keeping a dependable defender or by commanding a meaningful fee.

Tactically Johnston offers athleticism, overlapping runs and delivery that suits a team seeking width without relying on wingers. Everton would gain a modern full-back who presses and can join attacks, but they must accept the usual caveats: positional discipline and adaptation to Premier League tempo are not guaranteed overnight.

The Guru’s read: this is a test-balloon, not a closed deal. Expect Everton to probe further and possibly table an offer if Celtic’s valuation can be met, but Celtic will not sell cheaply; Everton should only pursue Johnston if they are prepared to guarantee playing time or meet a significant fee. My recommendation: Everton decide now whether Johnston is a long-term solution or a short-term patch — act decisively or walk away.